top of page

Scentwork Training: Is Your Dog Following Their Nose… or Following You?

Oct 31
5 min read
Basset Hound searching Chairs

How our little habits during training can influence a scentwork search without us even realising it.


Meet Cadi. She's a fictional dog, but her little scentwork dilemma might sound familiar!

Cadi loves searching. She enthusiastically investigates the first few objects, nose working away, until suddenly she stops and looks at her handler.

Her handler waits a moment.

Cadi stares.

"Go on, find it!"

Cadi looks again.

Her handler takes a couple of steps towards the hide, and Cadi follows. A few seconds later, she's found it!

Everyone celebrates.


But here's an interesting question: did Cadi find the hide using her nose, or did her handler help her find the answer?


And more importantly, what might Cadi be learning from these little interactions?


Are we helping a little too much?


When we do scentwork with our dogs, we spend a lot of time learning to read their body language. But have you ever considered how much information they're getting from ours?

Sometimes we're giving away clues without even noticing.


We might:

  • Slow down or stop walking as the dog approaches the hide.

  • Tighten the lead when they're getting close.

  • Point towards an area or turn our body in that direction.

  • Suddenly go quiet when they're near the target odour.

  • Keep repeating the search cue or encouraging them to carry on.

  • Step in to help at the first sign of difficulty.


None of this is necessarily deliberate. We're trying to help our dogs succeed!

But dogs are excellent observers. If our movements, voice or gestures regularly provide useful clues, they may start paying more attention to us and less attention to the odour.


Perhaps during scentwork training Cadi has learnt that looking at her handler is a useful part of the searching game.

Does this mean we should stop helping our dogs? Absolutely not!

Being a good scentwork handler also means knowing when to offer support. The important thing is to recognise whether our help is actually helping the dog learn or simply providing the answer.

So how can we explore what's happening with our own dogs?


Try the Silent Handler Challenge


Here's a little exercise you can try.

Set up an easy, familiar search using a line-up of boxes or other suitable objects. Place a familiar target odour in an accessible location.

We don't want to make the search difficult. We're interested in what happens when we change our behaviour, not in testing how complicated a hide our dog can solve.

Before starting, ask yourself:


What do I expect my dog to do?

For this exercise, we'd like the dog to investigate the objects, locate the target odour and offer their usual indication without additional guidance from us.


Now choose one of these variations:

  1. Stay behind the start line while your dog searches.

  2. Sit on a chair rather than moving around with your dog.

  3. Keep your hands behind your back to avoid gesturing or pointing, but you are free to follow your dog.


Choose just one variation at a time, and make sure your dog can search comfortably and safely with that setup.


Give your usual search cue once, then stay quiet and observe.

If your dog stops and looks back at you, resist the temptation to immediately say something or point them in the right direction.

Give them a little time.

What happens next?

Do they return to searching? Do they try something different? Or do they continue waiting for you?

Whatever happens, you're gathering useful information about how your team works together.

And remember, this isn't a test your dog has to pass. Changing your usual handling routine might be unfamiliar to them, so a little hesitation doesn't automatically mean they're relying on your help.


What if my dog doesn't resume searching during scentwork training?


First of all, don't turn it into a battle of wills.

If your dog remains stuck or starts becoming frustrated, calmly end the search.

You don't have to make sure they find that hide.

Instead, prepare a completely new, simpler search that gives them a better opportunity to succeed independently.

There's no need to go back to the original hide and guide them towards it just to finish the exercise with a find.

The aim isn't to leave our dogs struggling, nor is it to find every hide at any cost.

We want dogs who enjoy searching, have confidence in their abilities and can work through appropriate challenges.

And sometimes the most useful thing we can do as handlers is recognise that we need to change the exercise.


Back to Cadi…


Let's imagine Cadi's handler decides to try the challenge.

They set up a simple line-up of boxes and choose to stay behind the start line.

Cadi begins searching, investigates a few boxes and then pauses.

She looks back at her handler.

This time, nobody says anything.

Cadi waits a moment, then turns back towards the boxes and resumes investigating.

A little more sniffing and she's found the target odour!

Brilliant! Her handler can reward her and celebrate that independent search.

But perhaps things don't go quite so smoothly.

What if Cadi keeps looking back and doesn't resume searching?

That's useful information too.

Her handler can calmly finish the exercise and plan an easier search for next time. Perhaps Cadi needs more experience working away from her handler, or perhaps there's something else about the setup that needs adjusting.

Either way, the handler has learnt something.

And they've probably discovered that standing still and keeping quiet is surprisingly difficult!


Helping isn't the same as giving the answer


The Silent Handler Challenge is an exercise in observation, not a rule for how we should handle every search.

Sometimes our dogs genuinely need support. They might be struggling with a difficult problem, searching in an area where odour is behaving unexpectedly or simply not understanding what we're asking them to do.

A good handler learns to recognise when to give the dog a little more time, when to offer appropriate support and when it's better to change the exercise altogether.


The goal isn't to remove ourselves from the search. It's to become better partners.


But what if my dog still keeps looking at me?

Unintentional handler cues are only one piece of the puzzle.

Perhaps your dog has learnt to rely on your help, the searches have become too difficult, or searching isn't quite as rewarding as it used to be. Or perhaps there's something else going on that we haven't considered!

Different problems can look surprisingly similar, but they don't necessarily need the same solution.


The challenge isn't simply getting the dog to search again. It's understanding why they stopped in the first place.


And that's what I find so fascinating about scentwork. Every dog approaches a search differently, and there's always something new for us handlers to discover.


It's also one of the things I enjoy about our Scent Detectives Club: exploring these little details together, experimenting with different searches and helping each dog develop their skills at their own pace.

After all, scentwork should be fun for both ends of the lead!


Happy training!

Alessia

Cardiff Dog Training Academy

Comments


2023 - CDTA - Cardiff Dog Training Academy

bottom of page